Thursday, October 17, 2024

Gone With the Wind Reacion


Gone With the Wind
is a critically acclaimed film that has transcended time, giving a cultural significance for decades after the Civil War. As the film starts, viewers are transported into the opulent world of the pre-Civil War South. The stunning sets and costumes, rich in frills and extravagant details, not only reflect the wealth of characters like Scarlett O'Hara but also highlight their disconnection from the harsh realities faced by slaves and working-class whites.

This excess contrasts sharply with Scarlett's appearance at the end of Act 1 when she is worn down by hardship. Her plain clothes and simple fabrics mirror her personal growth and the changing world around her. Although she begins the film as a spoiled, entitled brat, Scarlett develops a gritty determination to survive, driven by her desire never again to experience the desperation she feels at that point. Her icon
ic soliloquy at Tara, where she vows never to go hungry again, is one of the film's most powerful scenes.

While the entire film is a masterpiece, it is Rhett Butler, played by Clark Gable, who truly captivated my interest. Early on, during a lavish party at Ashley Wilkes' home, Rhett stands out for his defiance of the Southern gentry’s confidence in a swift Confederate victory. Unlike the other men, Rhett argues that the South’s lack of industry and naval power meant it had no chance against the Union. His realistic perspective is mocked, but he simply leaves them to their misguided beliefs.

As the war progresses, Rhett amasses great wealth through blockade-running, food speculation, and gambling, making him an outcast among the Southern elite. They view his profiteering as morally unacceptable, even though many throughout history—like Andrew Carnegie during the Civil War or modern politicians during conflicts like the war in Afghanistan—have similarly enriched themselves through war. Although such actions are widespread, they remain morally wrong, as profiting from the suffering of others is indefensible.

What sets Rhett apart is his ultimate redemption. Despite his earlier detachment from the conflict, he eventually joins the Confederate Army in the final months of the war, driven by a desire to preserve the South he grew up in, even as it collapses. This decision, juxtaposed with his initial cynicism and pragmatic outlook, reveals the complexity of his character. His internal conflict between self-interest and loyalty makes Rhett one of the most intriguing figures in the film.

The film’s depiction of race remains controversial. Hattie McDaniel’s portrayal of Mammy earned her an Academy Award, yet the character of Prissy has drawn criticism for perpetuating offensive stereotypes. Scenes like Scarlett slapping Prissy during Melanie’s labor are uncomfortable, but they reflect the brutal reality of the time. While these depictions are troubling, erasing or sanitizing them risks ignoring the painful history they represent. Confronting these issues, rather than avoiding them, is essential to understanding the darker chapters of America's past.

In the end, Gone With the Wind is a complex, multifaceted film, with characters like Scarlett and Rhett embodying the moral and social struggles of the time. Its enduring legacy lies in its ability to provoke reflection on history, identity, and the choices we make.




No comments:

Post a Comment

Mock Trial: Bakke v. University of California

 Ladies and Gentlemen, Your Honor, we have come together today to discuss the injustice that has happened to Mr. Allan Bakke.  This case is ...